Testimonials

I brought a family heirloom into Gemsetter & Company, and Eric kindly took the time to evaluate the piece. He gave me a wonderful explanation of the individual elements of the ring. Other jewelers wanted to charge me a large price to give me the information that he did in ... a few minutes without charge. We also discussed the possibility of making the ring into several pendants. I am excited about the prospect, and I will hopefully be bringing that business to him soon! If you are looking for an honest and ethical jeweler, Eric Pettingill is your man! Read More

- Eileen Magill

Look no further- seriously. Eric was so completely amazing and helped me design the most beautiful new setting for a ring that my mother left me. I cannot even believe how beautiful his craftsmanship is! He was really patient and kind and helped bring my vision to life- then completely ... exceeded my expectations. I now have a gorgeous piece of jewelry that makes me think of my mom and that's completely priceless to me. Speaking of price- I received THREE quotes before coming to Eric and his was the best price by far. I am a customer for life! Read More

- Heather M.

Eric created my dream wedding band using my moms diamonds. I'm so thrilled about the result! He gives the best advice and isn't pushy. Such a wonderful man and jeweler. Read More

- Emilie Frances

Eric was amazing from start to finish on our custom engagement ring. I was just engaged yesterday and I couldn't stop the tears from flowing after seeing the ring. It was beyond what we ever could have expected. I cannot thank him enough for my beautiful work of art. It's ... a one of a kind showpiece. Read More

- Becky Marnell

Wow! The reviews on here don't lie! Eric is amazing! From my first conversation with him on the phone, I could tell he was knowledgable. When I brought in a ring to have resized, he was very forthright with how his team would go about fixing it. He made me ... feel very reassured that my jewelry was in good hands. And even better, it only took a few days!! I will be going back here for all my jewelry needs! Read More

- Katherine Penna

My friend had recommended Eric at Gemsetters because she had several pieces of jewelry she wanted made...She gets many compliments on the jewelry he helped her to design...I bought a gold necklace from him and had him put on charms on my grandmother's charm bracelet...I then expressed a desire to ... design a ring and after my poor attempt at describing and drawing it, he came up with a design that was spot on! He is currently on the lookout for gems to complete the project...He is a very nice, friendly, professional man...I recommend him highly! Read More

- Susan S.

Great service and great work. I went in to get a ring resized and cleaned. The owner was really helpful and friendly, the ring came out looking like new. Read More

- Paul V.

I have been a loyal and satisfied customer for more than 12 years, and wouldn't trust my jewelry to anyone else. Eric is the best in the business!

- Barbara A. Daniels

I inherited my grandfather's solitaire diamond necklace after he passed, and I had wanted it to become part of my wedding set. With something so near and dear to my heart and so sentimental, I knew I had to find someone I could trust to handle creating something new out ... of the old. The big box jewelry stores made me nervous (told me they had to "send it out") and almost every one tried to get me to purchase a new stone. When I took the diamond to Eric, I explained its significance, and he handled it with care and recognized the beauty in it. I felt completely comfortable. I turned over the diamond to my now husband, and he had a great experience picking out a setting with Eric. After the proposal, we returned to have custom bands designed and created. Eric is so knowledgeable and so creative! His excitement about what he does is refreshing...you can tell he loves his craft. We ended up with the most gorgeous and unique rings, complete with black diamonds. I get compliments everywhere I go! Upon picking up the rings, we asked Eric if he had taken a picture for his portfolio. He told us that he doesn't use a portfolio, because every custom ring should be unique, and he doesn't want couples coming in and picking one of those as their own. I thought that was a wonderful thing...it shows how much he cares about his previous clients, and how much effort he will put into finding something unique and great for his future clients. Read More

- Ashley O.

Eric is AMAZING!!! I will never go to another jeweler again. He is the nicest man and knows everything about jewelry. He made life so easy for my now husband and I and took the 70 year old platinum diamond engagement ring that has been in my husband's family and ... made it look brand new and perfectly sized it. He even built and customized my wedding ring to go perfectly with my engagement ring that my husband and Eric designed together. I couldn't ask for a better jeweler and person. He helped me pick out the perfect wedding ring for my husband and even gave me a 15% discount. He also saved my Aunt's 2 carat diamond ring she's had for 20 years from falling out and she is so grateful! Thank you so much Eric!!! I've recommended you to everyone! Read More

- Jenn F.

I could easily be the spokesperson for Gemsetter! I have been coming here for years and have purchased some beautiful pieces. My last ring had a mishap and Eric repaired my ring and stood behind his craftsmanship! Not many would do what Eric and Gemsetter did. I'm so happy, my ... ring is gorgeous and you can bet I'll tell this experience to many and recommend Gemsetter and Company! ❤️❤️❤️ Read More

- Kathy Murphy Abbott

Eric is the best! He can make whatever you can imagine. Stands behind every piece and the work is fabulous. He won't steer you wrong just to make a buck! Truly a class act!

- Donna Bach

Write Your Own

Schedule Appointment

Please feel free to contact us.